No matter how small, businesses in today’s digital age must be fully mobile-enabled. That means not only making it easy for customers to do business with you via their mobile devices, but enabling employees to be mobile as well.

Smartphones have become critical to keeping on-the-move employees productive. According to the recent Maximizing Mobile Value study by Oxford Economics and Samsung, 57 percent of employees say that smartphones are now essential to their jobs. The average business has nearly six business applications deployed, two of which are proprietary apps developed specifically for their workforce or customers.

Yet small businesses owners remain split on one critical decision: Should they allow employees to use their own smartphones for work purposes (commonly referred to as Bring Your Own Device, or BYOD) or furnish them with corporate-owned devices? The choice involves balancing the challenges around productivity, security and cost.

In 2022, just 15 percent of small and medium businesses provide smartphones to all employees. Another 46 percent offer them to some employees, typically based on seniority, while the remaining 39 percent rely entirely on their employees’ personal phones, according to the Maximizing Mobile Value research.

The hidden costs of BYOD

Allowing employees to use their own mobile phone for work might seem the simpler solution — after all, 85 percent of Americans own a smartphone and keep it with them at all times. But there are several downsides to BYOD when it comes to security, productivity and operational efficiency.

Mobile security is the most urgent concern for many businesses, particularly when it comes to sensitive corporate data. If employees own their devices, it’s much more difficult to ensure data remains protected.

Shop special offers

Find out about offers on the latest Samsung technology.

see deals

Speak to a solutions expert

Get expert advice from a solutions consultant.

Talk to an expert

Will your employees download the current versions of security patches? Will they protect their devices appropriately with passwords or biometric authentication? In a BYOD environment, businesses depend on employees to make the right choices for the company’s security.

At the same time, there’s the issue of business continuity. As your employees become increasingly dependent on mobile connectivity and apps, what happens when their personal phone breaks? Without a backup plan in place, it may take that employee longer to get their device fixed than it would to simply swap out a company-owned device.

With corporate-liable phones, companies can implement processes to ensure that configurations, security and repair procedures are standardized. Businesses can also ensure employees always have the latest versions of apps and security patches by pushing updates through an enterprise mobility management (EMM) system.

Mobile device management

To achieve security standards and to manage corporate use of mobile applications, businesses must deploy a mobile device management (MDM) platform. If the company is providing the phones, they can install the MDM client and make it clear they are managing the devices and apps.

A BYOD device policy comes with different rules and expectations because the devices are the property of the employees. Businesses can ask employees to install an MDM client on their phone, but employees may be resistant to company monitoring and having limitations set on their use of a personal device.

It’s certainly possible to manage devices and applications in the BYOD model, but as you might expect, it requires a careful balance. The company’s BYOD policy should clearly explain the requirements for personally owned devices, which applications are allowlisted or blocklisted, and how the company will use EMM to manage the devices.

Some companies will choose to offer a mobile stipend as a compromise. Since employees are receiving some compensation, they will be more accepting of the device being managed, and businesses are wise to evaluate their device policy in this light. The cost of the stipend and the added burdens and risks that come with BYOD might tip the scale in favor of issuing company-owned devices. With corporate-liable devices, companies gain greater control over data, apps and how the devices can be used. With these corporate controls implemented, companies can also ensure that security protocols and patches are always up to date.

Cost considerations

You might think you’d come out ahead on cost with BYOD, but that’s not always the case. According to the research from Oxford Economics, while the upfront costs may favor the BYOD approach, other hidden costs make it a less obvious choice. For example, those monthly stipends cost an average $40.20 per month, per employee.

Mobile device management for beginners

icon of a document
White Paper

Get started with MDM so your organization can spend less and do more — securely and efficiently. Download Now

In addition, businesses can often take advantage of negotiated discount rates and service plans with carriers and volume discounts with device providers. In general, businesses with headcounts as low as 10 can expect to save money buying the phones themselves.

When choosing between BYOD and the corporate liable model, it pays to consider your options carefully. Think about how your employees use smartphones today and how your business is likely to further embrace mobility over time. Weigh the pros and cons, not only for economic reasons, but for security, productivity and manageability. Taking these steps, a clearer path forward will begin to emerge.

If you’re considering a mobile deployment, here’s a comprehensive mobile roadmap to guide you. Want to update your BYOD policy? Follow our template to help you get started.

Posts By

Karen D. Schwartz

Karen Schwartz has more than 20 years of experience writing about technology and business issues across the spectrum, including government, small business, education and channel. Schwartz has written about everything from telecommunications to outsourcing for industry-leading publications like CIO, InformationWeek, eWeek, Government Executive and PC Magazine, in addition to dozens of ghostwritten white papers, articles and case studies for companies like Microsoft Corp., Comcast, Dell, Unisys Corp. and CDW.

View more posts by Karen D. Schwartz