Optimize Your Banking Customer Service

Get your free guide to meeting the customer service expectations of today's banking consumer.

Download Now
Wealth Management

Investors Say They Want Both Robo-Advisors and Human Advice

Robo-advisors are gaining trust from investors who are now seeking a combination of high-tech and human advice. In High-Tech and High Touch: Investors Make the Case for Converging Automated Investing Platforms and Financial Planning, the Financial Planning Association (FPA) and Investopedia found that 73 percent of respondents were satisfied with their automated investing platforms (AIPs), compared to 75 percent with traditional financial advisors. The 31-40 age group showed the highest percentage of AIP usage at 11 percent. Not surprisingly, the 61+ age group had the least usage, at 4 percent.

The study also found that 58 percent of respondents were somewhat familiar with AIPs, while 18 percent have searched for an AIP. However, only 7 percent are currently using one, suggesting room for growth and deeper market penetration.

Conventional banks are listening to their customers and providing high-tech solutions in combination with human advice. In a pilot program launching in 2017, Wells Fargo Advisors is teaming up with FinTech firm SigFig to roll out a robo-advisor platform that targets “emerging investors.” By introducing a digital advisory offering alongside their network of over 15,000 traditional financial advisors, the nation’s second largest bank is addressing the migration to robo-advisors by millennials, while also providing traditional personal financial advisors. Rather than seeing automation as a threat to personal advising, Wells Fargo believes the two groups can seamlessly coexist to generate a two-pronged, cross-selling cumulative effect on the bottom line.

Disruptive technology is revolutionizing banks.

icon of a documentWhite Paper

Cutting-edge finance startups are changing the way we think about banking. Download Now

Coexistence or Cannibalism?

Traditional financial planners/advisors were still preferred over robo-advisors for financial services like estate, elder care, tax and healthcare planning. Financial services like investment planning, education funding and purchase financing services were tied. Financial advisors were still favored by 39 percent (versus 22 percent for robo-advisors) for investment planning services. However, another 39 percent of respondents preferred to use both. Advances in artificial intelligence and machine learning will inevitably broaden the depth and scope of robo-advisor services. While the data suggests that client acquisition is not a zero-sum game, it’s unclear just how much of the traditional financial advisor’s pipeline will be affected down the road.

Stubborn Baby Boomers

Robo-advisors are best suited for market-educated, self-directed and tech savvy investors. Not everyone embraces the technology, notably baby boomers who still prefer walking into brick-and-mortar bank branches to conduct business. Baby boomers are the most reluctant demographic to adopt FinTech, with trust being the major concern. However, this can be improved with stronger security and positive customer experiences.

With U.S. stock markets achieving new highs, the true stress test for robo-advisor clients will arise in the next bear market sell-off. Algorithms have no capacity for emotions, but investors do.

New technology like robo-advisors and AI are also playing a large role in reshaping FinTech hiring practices.

Posts By

Jea Yu

Jea Yu is a co-founder of Undergroundtrader.com, an online trader education site that has served over 10,000 traders, fund managers and investors worldwide since 1998 and was voted Forbes Best of the Web for four consecutive years in the active trader category. He has published best-sellers through McGraw-Hill, John Wiley and Bloomberg Press and has been interviewed in popular periodicals including the Wall Street Journal, Stocks & Commodities, the Financial Times, Active Trader Magazine, Traders Magazine and USA Today. Follow him on Twitter: @jeayu21

View more posts by Jea Yu